An authentic life is the most personal form of worship.
Everyday life has become my prayer.
- Sarah Ban Breathnach
In an effort to try and untangle my recent wrestling with faith, with paths that end, and with myself, I am going to attempt to take apart what has been making me question and doubt. As I had mentioned in the post about running the Peachtree, the song 'Existence' by August Burns Red stretched right across my chest and seemed to echo what I could not yet name. I will dismantle the lyrics that resonate.
The walls of a church don't make it holy.
It's what's authentic that completes the sum of it's parts.
Lately, this. I am just being honest here. I have reached a point of stagnation when I attend our church. I don't know why, exactly. Let me start by saying this isn't an indictment on my church or an attempt to lay blame there. I will be the first to admit - I am not involved like I once was. I go. I take up a chair. I walk back out into the blinding sunshine, sometimes not having had any real connection to anyone there. I go in carrying a wisp of hope for something, and leave longing for it still.
What is it? What are my bones aching for? Where do I find 'it'?
I think what it seems to be (and I still hold this tentative, balanced precariously in my hands like an heirloom teacup) is that when I compare it to the moments lately that I have experienced unity and a drawing nigh to the bosom of God, it has been among strangers where 'real' and 'organic' are present. It is a desire for real, even if it means raw and broken. Is that weird? Let me try to explain the contrast I feel.
There were YEARS that I endured the shiny and shellacked fronts of a group of people called 'church' where I attended before - the "Hi, how are you? I am FINE! Blessed! How are you? Fine! Fine!" All the while your soul is gasping and the chambers of your heart squeezing from the pain you may be going through, but 'FINE! Dandy!' falls from the lips. I don't think it is this exactly but close. It seems as if we converge and gather as individuals, slip into our familiar rows surrounded by the same folks in their usual places, the lights go down, the music cranks up and then we sit in unison to listen in quiet to one person share their 3-point message before we are released with a blessing on the week and spill out onto the sidewalk that leads us all away.
I know. There has to be a reaching out. 'Why don't you join/sign up for a community group?' I'm guilty - I haven't reached out and it has been years since I was a part of such a group. Right now that feels forced.
A few weeks ago I attended a concert with a dear friend from high school. That is our 'thing' - we get together once or twice a year for concerts. It was the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra performing the music of U2. I didn't know what to expect. I was leery - how could they replicate greatness? I didn't realize until I got there that someone would actually be singing the songs with the ASO. Who could sing like Bono? His name is Brody Dolyniuk and he was fabulous.
It was there that I texted Hubs and commented that I had just had church, more than when I sat in the familiar blue rows on Sunday. He questioned me, but my reply was the same. What was it, then?
First it came when the entire audience sang 'With or Without You' together. Then the band and Brody cranked up a rousing rendition of 'Pride (In The Name of Love) and the crowd sprang to their feet, all of us, singing at the top of our lungs - 'In the name of love!' I looked around and it seemed every race and nationality was represented there - the precious tiny Asian family beside me, the family with rambunctious boys one row in front. The man, alone, dancing and moving in such a way with all the markings of some sort of exceptionality. Dark faces and pale ones all, upturned and singing, 'In the name of love'.
This gripped me with such a love for people, for these beautiful beings.
Other experiences with similar responses - a front porch and a guitar; skin-to-skin in a public transit train, seeing strangers laugh together; walking through a sculpted wonder with a little family with a baby girl named Trinity; sitting at the kitchen table of a long-time friend, talking (Hi, Dorothy!); witnessing a man with tears streaming down while he sang , 'Live Like You Were Dying'. I wanted to kiss his streaked face, I hurt for him so deeply.
Why is this, when in church, I am also surrounded by faces, all singing, all human just the same?
Are there invisible walls up in church where there are none elsewhere?
Are the walls ones that I built?
Am I the one least authentic?
I wrestle still - how do I bridge this divide?
What is it? What are my bones aching for? Where do I find 'it'?
I think what it seems to be (and I still hold this tentative, balanced precariously in my hands like an heirloom teacup) is that when I compare it to the moments lately that I have experienced unity and a drawing nigh to the bosom of God, it has been among strangers where 'real' and 'organic' are present. It is a desire for real, even if it means raw and broken. Is that weird? Let me try to explain the contrast I feel.
There were YEARS that I endured the shiny and shellacked fronts of a group of people called 'church' where I attended before - the "Hi, how are you? I am FINE! Blessed! How are you? Fine! Fine!" All the while your soul is gasping and the chambers of your heart squeezing from the pain you may be going through, but 'FINE! Dandy!' falls from the lips. I don't think it is this exactly but close. It seems as if we converge and gather as individuals, slip into our familiar rows surrounded by the same folks in their usual places, the lights go down, the music cranks up and then we sit in unison to listen in quiet to one person share their 3-point message before we are released with a blessing on the week and spill out onto the sidewalk that leads us all away.
I know. There has to be a reaching out. 'Why don't you join/sign up for a community group?' I'm guilty - I haven't reached out and it has been years since I was a part of such a group. Right now that feels forced.
A few weeks ago I attended a concert with a dear friend from high school. That is our 'thing' - we get together once or twice a year for concerts. It was the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra performing the music of U2. I didn't know what to expect. I was leery - how could they replicate greatness? I didn't realize until I got there that someone would actually be singing the songs with the ASO. Who could sing like Bono? His name is Brody Dolyniuk and he was fabulous.
It was there that I texted Hubs and commented that I had just had church, more than when I sat in the familiar blue rows on Sunday. He questioned me, but my reply was the same. What was it, then?
First it came when the entire audience sang 'With or Without You' together. Then the band and Brody cranked up a rousing rendition of 'Pride (In The Name of Love) and the crowd sprang to their feet, all of us, singing at the top of our lungs - 'In the name of love!' I looked around and it seemed every race and nationality was represented there - the precious tiny Asian family beside me, the family with rambunctious boys one row in front. The man, alone, dancing and moving in such a way with all the markings of some sort of exceptionality. Dark faces and pale ones all, upturned and singing, 'In the name of love'.
This gripped me with such a love for people, for these beautiful beings.
Other experiences with similar responses - a front porch and a guitar; skin-to-skin in a public transit train, seeing strangers laugh together; walking through a sculpted wonder with a little family with a baby girl named Trinity; sitting at the kitchen table of a long-time friend, talking (Hi, Dorothy!); witnessing a man with tears streaming down while he sang , 'Live Like You Were Dying'. I wanted to kiss his streaked face, I hurt for him so deeply.
Why is this, when in church, I am also surrounded by faces, all singing, all human just the same?
Are there invisible walls up in church where there are none elsewhere?
Are the walls ones that I built?
Am I the one least authentic?
I wrestle still - how do I bridge this divide?


I got nothing. I never felt comfortable in Baptist church with my hubby. Too much hellfire and damnation (the ones we tried out) i was raised Lutheran but still felt out of place. Now I just feed hundreds on Sundays (trust me, I still pray and worship on my own time) and leave church alone. Maybe someday it will call me back.
ReplyDeleteFunny, THANK YOU for being the brave one to even attempt to reply to such a post as this. I think your comment has even helped me to sort out this particular aspect of my disequilibrium.
DeleteI know what you mean - the church I referred to in my post, the 'Hi how are you? I'm fine!' church was a baptist church. Lovely people there, but near the end of our time there, I could literally feel the oppression, like the oxygen was leaving the room every Sunday. Our current one is nondenom, but with baptist underpinnings.
Thank you for this, Funny. This has helped, more than you know. A post will surely follow as I continue to sort it out in my mind.
I have found that our small group of men that meet each week for lunch to talk about being Men of God was the most worshipful, especially during group prayer time. So, maybe a small group (10 or less) would help you worship better than a large group. When it is small, you can't hide and you HAVE to be authentic.
ReplyDeleteBut, each individual is made different, and God wants to be part of each life in some way. I am praying for you.
Yes, I know that a small group of some sort would be good - but I don't want it to be forced or contrived. We have a group person that helps to situate people in groups.....and I just don't want it to be yet another 'Hi how are you, I'm fine' kind of situation...Finding a group of misfits would probably be the best scenario for me - ha ha.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the prayers!
I am not churched. I have tried many times in different places and various associations. It does not work for me, the environment is sterile, devoid of real human emotion and interaction, and all too often the undercurrents of church politics and alliances rear their ugly head.
ReplyDeleteI remember once being a new member to a congregation and was told by a person I sat next to "You can't sit there, so and so always sits there." Wow, did I ever feel welcome! I have learned that I do not belong.
I want to see a vibrant faith in action, love in action, not a prescribed pretense of holiness and smug satisfaction. I can't do it. If that is wrong, then I shall be damned for it, but I will continue to worship God in my own way, and seek His leading when it comes to sharing that love with others.
Josie.......(tears welling). Thank you. Thank you for being so honest and transparent. This means the world to me, to validate the feelings I often feel surface when I slip into the rows of my church. It isn't an indictment of my church, but some incongruity within me. I just need to find where the edges match.
ReplyDelete